Hi. Sorry, repeated question but I searched and ugh I kept getting answers about the canned stuff you mix yourself. My question is about the Atkins Advantage premade stuff in the cans....

Can they stall people like the bars?

I remember reading a few times that the shakes are different, but then I'll read someone say they aren't....Eh I'm confused again...

Bars stall me out if I eat more than 1/2 every so often.

I drink shakes M-F as suppliment to breakfast and/or snack since the beginning and they have not caused me problems.

There are different ingredients between bars and shakes.

Yvonne,

what is m-f, is this a brand name, sorry if it sounds stupid,

I have the Atkin's shakes both powder and premade at least 3-4 times a week and I think it has actually helped me lose weight! It has not stalled me at all. I noticed on the days I have had shakes like 2 times in a row the next day I have a pound that I have lost. Don't know if it has anything to do with the shakes but they do not stall me at all.

Stallqueen M-F is Monday through Friday

I think she means Monday through Friday.

Yep that's what I thought. Just had to double check. Thanks.

The one bad thing I found from the shakes is that for me it umm... increases flatulance. So they are out of my diet.

ohmygod! NOw I feel stupid.

Thanks,

So I assume that me having one eas carb control shake a day will be fine then

I love them.