The Atkins Advantage bars- Chocolate Cononut a 10! It is my fav so far. Chocolate Decadence, Cookies and Cream, Frosted Cinnamon and Pralines and Cream (the new version) are all a 9. The rest of the flavors very, but on average probaly a 6 or 7 except for the MOCHA CRUNCH- YUCK!
The Atkins ready made shakes (I have not tried the mix as of yet)-
The vanilla is a 9, the chocalate is a 10 and the strawberry is a 3 (too artificial and sweet tasting.) I like the shakes because there is no hidden carbs that I can find.
The Atkins breakfast bars- Lemon Poppyseed, the only good use for this bar is to create a brick wall in your house. They are nasty. I can't believe they are still on the market. HOWEVER, the CREAMY CINNAMON BUN BREAKFAST BAR IS AWESOME... I would give it a 9 or a 10. (It gets a 10 when I find them on sale for $3.99 a box!)
The Atkins Bake Mix- YUCK! I bought a can about a month after induction. I can't even remember what I tried to make the first time but I know I was disapointed. Then I make fried chicken with it. ALL I COULD TASTE WAS SOY. A few months later I threw the can out (it expired) and I have not bought it since.
The Atkins Blueberry muffins- I thought were really good, a 7 or an 8. Makes a lot of muffins but I only bought it once.
Atkins Brownie Mix- This is a mixed bag. I loved the flavor! If you ate only one, that would be fine. However, who can stop at one brownie. Problem is, if you do not stop at one, you will be in the bathroom for the next few hours. Rating on taste- a 9+. Rating on after effect is a negitive 100.
Atkins Pancake Mix- I bought this a few weeks ago. I like it a lot. I would give it an 8. So, it taste different than so-called real pancakes. I knew it would. But I still enjoyed them.
Atkins Indugle bars-
The chocolate bar is good I will give it a 7 1/2. (I would rather get russell stovers sugar free milk chocalte truffles. You get three servings of 3 truffles per bag- which equals 9 truffles. made with maltinol, carbs for sugar alcohol is about the same as the Indulge bar. However, it taste better and cost $1.69 for 3 servings where you pay about $1.49 for one serving of Indulge.)
The Atkins Carmel Nut Chew is good. I like it because it is satisfying. I would give it an 8. However, same as above, the russell stover's sugar free carmel nut chews are better.
The Atkins Peanut Butter cups- are good. I would give it an 8 but I am not a big peanut butter fan. I only had this once.
Atkins Steak sauce- This was one of the first Atkins products I bought. I liked it a lot in the beginning. However, now I think it is too sweet. I would give it an 8 if you still haven't got the sugar cravings out of your system. Once you do, it drops down to a 5.
I think this is a great poll. These products can get expensive so its great to hear what others think.
I have a question for those that rated the shakes... Were you rating the ready-made or the mix? I do not want to spend $20.00 on the mix if it is only fair. I drink the ready mades every now and then and that is enough for me. However, if you didn't like the ready made (as you can see, I do) then maybe the mix will be good. Oh, well I will wait and see the other replies!
Again, great post! Thanks!