Hiya willbthin,

welcome to the site! well I'm right there with you for I have tried CAD, somersizing, and now I am on Atkins' for the second time. This go around is even harder than the first so now i wish I had just stuck with it then...but we can't go back now can we...(darn it)...lol What ever you choose it, you will know right away if it is for you or not, and if you could do it for a lifetime....that is what I'm dealing with right now not just can I get to my goal wieght..( which is a long way off) but can I accept this WOE for the rest of my life....well as they say "one day at a time"