Thu, Nov-20-03, 21:15
|
|
Senior Member
Posts: 3,423
|
|
Plan: Atkins (loosely)
Stats: -/-/-
BF:
Progress: 40%
Location: Ottawa, Ontario
|
|
Atkins diet on CBCNEWS
I saw a small blurb on the Atkins diet today on the news. In the preview you saw a father holding a picture of his daughter and saying don't let your family go on Atkins or you too might loose a son or daughter.
I was concerned that the reports it would consist of more baseless attacks, but I was pleasantly suprised. In the end it was fairly balanced. The report begun with a man blaming his heart disease on Atkins and again the father who lost his daughter and blames it on the diet. Then a short blurb on Neal Barnyard spewing his usual spiel and calling for an inquiry.
That was followed by the voice of wisdom in the form of a scientific looking guy in a lab coat (didn't catch the name) saying there was nothing in the Atkins diet that could possibly cause sudden death.
Then they mentioned that some studies had been positive.
But, here goes the best part, they actually exposed the PCRM agenda, saying they are a vegan group who naturally opposed the eating of meat.
All in all a fair report. They did give air time to more anti-Atkins drivel, but at least they countered it with a balanced opposing view.
ps
I really feel sorry for the father who lost his daugther. Here he is thinking that the diet caused his dauther's death. This must mean that he feels he could have prevented that death, had he only known. This is totally unfair to place this burden of guilt on him when she probably died of some pre-existing condition. Just one more example of how one bad diagnostic can end up hurting people
Last edited by Angeline : Thu, Nov-20-03 at 21:20.
|