I just had my first (and probably last) Atkins shake today--Cafe au Lait. Pretty bad. First sign of trouble was the label that said to drink it "very cold," which is probably because number taste buds from a very cold drink are probably easier to fool than fully sensitive taste buds.

The shake smelled like fish---I kid you not--and it tasted awful. I even checked the expiration date on it and it had many months to go. I'm glad I tried it and I'm glad I don't have to drink those, either. Maybe others enjoy them or maybe the other flavors are better, but for me, Cafe au Lait shake is off the list!