That didn't really answer my question.

Why do you say Atkin's induction works but the later stages do not? During induction you eat carbs all day long....same as during OWL. Some Atkin's followers stay around 30 carbs a day during OWL. Are you saying 30 carbs as opposed to 20 carbs a day doesn't work?

I think this needs to be more specific as to number of carbs one eats as to just making a blanket statement that anything but Atkin's induction doesn't work for a carb addict. Wouldn't you agree?

I don't know many people following Atkin's that needs to eat every couple of hours. We tend to find more people than not lose their appietite and barely eat one or two meals a day.

I would really love to see your research numbers on this. Like how many people that are on Atkin's that you have followed for 6 months or more, as opposed to people on CAD for 6 months or more and do a comparison on the two groups.