Jonathan,

If you really beleive listing others who share your opinion constitutes enough scientific proof, then I rest my case.

I was annoyed, since you did make that claim that you have read scientific journals to substantiate your claims.

Now that you corrected that claim, and admit it is based only on other websites published opinions, then I'm no longer annoyed.

In our published list, we have a dedicates page for opinions against low-carb diets:

http://www.lowcarb.ca/newsmenu/opinionagainst.html

I have no problems with such claims, and I point people to them all the time.

I simply want to to make the distinction between science based on proven facts, vs. opinions. If you can't see the difference, I don't know what else to say.

Wa'il