Hmm.. Let me look here, in my cynic's dictionary:
Naturopath n. 1) someone trying to dish medical advice with no credentials. see also quack

Frankly, I'm surprised you bothered to keep the thread going that long.

I think the core of her argument is still somewhat sound, though: give up all carbs, and you'll have colon problems. Something to keep in mind when people accuse Atkinsers of not eating any carbs. We know better.