It just bolsters my argument that it is not a one size fits all diet world. What works well for one metabolic type may not work for another metabolic type. We need to stop making generalizations and extrapolating one person's/group's success with a particular diet on to the whole population. I think there might be indicators as to which diet is best for which group. I think that type II diabetes and insulin resistance is a clear indication that a person's body chemistry is out of balance and that that person needs a lc diet.