well I would LOVE to be in this group with you all...I eat all of my meals and snack(s) too...SO if I lose more than 8 in a month promise not to kick me out! lol SO far my loss has been unpredictable really...5 pounds a week sometimes 4 pounds a month..sometimes no loss in a month .... BUT If my average is 4-8 pounds a month throughout the year that would be excellent! each of those stinkers adds right up! I am in a couple groups hoping that one will be THE onbe or maybe they all will! I am always needing a ton of support to keep going.