VERY interesting, thanks for posting.Naturally I was rooting for Atkins, I am on Dr Bernstien's Diabetes diet which is a close cousin. I will say that my choir director has lost maybe 20 or 25 lbs on WW, it has been about 9 months for her. But I notice when we have parties and potlucks and stuff, she kind of abstains or stays home while I eat lowcarb stuff and do not starve.