I bought Maple Grove Farms syrup at Cracker Barrel the other night and I think is is excellent. It's not really thick, but I think it is very much like real maple syrup, which isn't very thick. If it's taste you are looking for, I think you would be pleased with the maple flavor. I notice you are in WA, so you may not have Cracker Barrel restaurants there. Maple Grove Farms is in Vermont according to the label. Another thing I thought of is this - you can buy maple flavoring at the grocery store. I haven't checked, but my guess is, it probably has no carbs. You could add a little to some of the syrup you already have and see if that helps at all.