Sigh -- if they would read DANDR and the studies in there, or have their librarians do a MEDLINE search, they would see that the water loss issue has been addressed, wouldn't they. Instead, they want another study, which will show what they want it to show, or can be "spun" to do so. And, you know, they're never going to apologize, are they? Say "we were so wrong, we wonder why anybody would listen to us now." Like the moron psychiatrists in the 50's who blamed autism on the mothers, "cold, uncaring" "refrigerator moms" the heartache they piled on those innocent women, and has anybody in the profession stepped up to the plate and admitted that they were half-cocked and caused huge hurt? The answer, as far as I can tell, is "no" Oh well.