Thread: Ketosis Unsafe?
View Single Post
  #7   ^
Old Wed, Jul-16-03, 20:21
timco timco is offline
Senior Member
Posts: 195
 
Plan: Atkins / Protein Power
Stats: 215/152/150 Male 68 inches
BF:
Progress: 97%
Location: New York City
Default

Thank you both for your replies. And thank you KoKo for taking the time to type all of that!

I followed caverjen's link and read that entire thread. I am still not convinced that there is anything wrong with ketosis. I think Scwarzbein is great and have read her first book and recommended it to a diabetic friend starting LCing, but I just don't think that her ketosis argument holds any water. This post says it better than I could:

Quote:
Originally Posted by doreen T
hi Deb,

I confess that I don't have SPII yet, so perhaps Dr. S. has addressed this elsewhere in her book. Just wanted to point out that yes, certain cells in the body lack mitochondria, which are necessary in order to use ketones in the Krebs (citric acid) cycle for energy. These cells require glucose instead.

I notice she uses the starvation model as her example In the case of a ketogenic diet, eg Atkins, or that used to treat epilepsy in young children, the person is consuming adequate protein in addition to the fat, and generally a minimal amount of carbohydrate too .. eg 20 grams. But even in the absence of any carbs from the diet, the liver will produce necessary glucose from proteins .. this is called gluconeogenesis. If the person is starving, then the liver will break down proteins from the body itself .. starting with recycled dead cells, etc, then muscle tissue. If adequate protein is consumed in the diet, then that is what will be used instead. So, even in the case of starvation, the body is never running 100% on ketones; there will always be a nominal amount of glucose being produced to supply those cells that need it.

It's a very long article, but if anyone has the time and is interested, this whole process is explained very well in Chuck Forsberg's Adiposity 101.

Doreen
Reply With Quote