I for one can relate to small pudgy feet. I wear a size 6 but in a wide width and they really don't cater to people with small feet. All the shoes look like something grandma would wear. Go up to a 7 or 8 and variety out the ying yang. I went looking for sandals the past couple of days and went to 5 different places. Today I finally went over to the boys section and got a 4 1/2 and they fit great. Nice and wide and they look surprisingly good on my foot. I have always had fat feet though. I could only wear stride rite, and saddle shoes for wide feet when I was a little girl. No black patent leather buckle shoes for this girl. My mom hated it!!!!