The closest thing I have found is "Natural" peanut butter. Locally, I buy a brand called "Crazy Richards" - I think this is a Northeast / midwest brand. It is made out of pure peanuts & that is it, nothing else. It took some getting used to - the oil on top has to be mixed in and it is def. not as sweet as Peter Pan, but I LOVE it now & will never go back to the hydrogenated oils in regular p/b

Also - locally - Shoppers Food Warehouse & Whole Foods carry the Natural p/b

Good luck