Everyone's tastes must be different, because I didn't like the EAS vanilla I tried at all. It wasn't thick, creamy, or good. I found it tasted like watered down skim milk. I much prefer the Atkins Brand personally. I wish I did like the EAS as they're cheaper & never seem to be out of stock. I did find they worked well for making low carb pudding though. I think they pre subtract the 2g fiber, so it really contains 2g net carbs at least that's what it said under the ingredients.
God Bless,
Amy-Lynne