The clincher for me is that many mice trying an Atkins diet die of a broken neck immediately after eating a tiny cube of cheese...

The assertion we have to call them on is: 50% carbs/40% fat is a high-fat diet and therefore any results can be used to judge Atkins' 10% carbs/70% fat (is that close?) diet.

I think I'll write the author a note to that effect.

By the way, here's the abstract