Active Low-Carber Forums

Active Low-Carber Forums (http://forum.lowcarber.org/index.php)
-   Atkins Diet (http://forum.lowcarber.org/forumdisplay.php?f=98)
-   -   High Protein (http://forum.lowcarber.org/showthread.php?t=164646)

adukart Wed, Feb-04-04 18:03

High Protein
 
I'm late going home so this will have to be a quick one. I don't understand, why do people keep saying that this is a high protein diet? I personally do not eat more protein than I did before. Is it maybe because the ratio of protein to other foods you eat is higher because you minus out the carbs? When I think about it though the ratio hasn't even changed for me. Hmm, maybe I've always been on a high protein diet?

Lisa N Wed, Feb-04-04 18:39

I think it's all a matter of definition. For some, anything more than 15-20% of your daily caloric intake from protein is considered "high". For others (like us), it's considered "adequte".
It's really a common misconception that low carb automatically means high protein. I think that is mostly since it's simply inconcievable to most people who have listened to the "fat is bad" dogma for the past few decades that we might actually be getting the majority of our calories from fat instead of protein. :rolleyes:

adkpam Wed, Feb-04-04 18:45

Gee, it would be even more inflammatory if they called it the "high fat" diet, wouldn't it?
Me, I'm getting MORE protein, and I think I needed it. According to what I've been researching, I'm finally getting ENOUGH protein.
But "adequate protein" diet just doesn't have the same ring.

mrschmelz Wed, Feb-04-04 18:48

The same people who call this a high protein diet are the ones who say you aren't allowed to have veggies during the strict induction period. Once lies are repeated over and over, they become truth in the eyes of most.

Personally I found that Atkins is TOO low of protein for my training needs. I now consume around 40% of my calories from Protein, isntead of the 25% or so when I was strictly following Atkins.

LadyBelle Wed, Feb-04-04 20:41

It's higher protien then what the perimid recomends, but moderate for what our bodies need.

I was reading one woman's book and it suggested women need around 25g of protien a day, with up around 70g while pregnant. That would be about one chicken breast and is no where near enough to meet basic needs :P

Sccuffy Wed, Feb-04-04 22:37

I think that there is alot of mis-information out there regarding low carb eating.

I have only been doing this for about 3 weeks, and I can't understand all the fear mongering in the press and by people who don't know what this woe is all about, I think that the media is being used by large corporation who make money off cheap carb loaded junk (I know it sounds like a consipricy (sp?) theory), but their are large multi-national conglomerates who make a tonn of cash of things like french fries etc.

I mean, on average how many people in north america have veggies at at least two meals a day? and that does not include french fries as a serving of veggies. I think that the so called Nutrisionists should look at what is really going on in people's lives and not just what they have been taught from a book / professor.

The modern diet is very screwed up, and obviously the information that the public has been given as a whole is not working for them, so they are finding their own solutions like Atkins.

Off on a rant, sorry, I will stop their.

Karen Thu, Feb-05-04 01:33

High protein? It's a holdover from the '70's.

I just love calling it a high fat diet. It puts fear in the eyes of the carb-hearted. :lol:

Karen

BawdyWench Thu, Feb-05-04 07:07

Everyone knows all you eat on Atkins is bacon and eggs and cheese!

:lol:

adukart Thu, Feb-05-04 09:39

Thanks for all the replys. I also wanted to make sure I was not the only one who doesn't call it a high protein diet, and I can see I'm not. Where I mostly see it is in the media, like magazines and articles like that, it doesn't matter whether they are for or against it they all still say it's a high protein diet.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:16.

Copyright © 2000-2024 Active Low-Carber Forums @ forum.lowcarber.org
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.